B4 and After: Managing Hierarchy, Partitioning, and Asymmetry for Availability and Scale in Google’s Software-Defined WAN

Private WANs are increasingly important to the operation of
enterprises, telecoms, and cloud providers. For example, B4,
Google’s private software-defined WAN, is larger and growing
faster than our connectivity to the public Internet. In this
paper, we present the five-year evolution of B4. We describe
the techniques we employed to incrementally move from
offering best-effort content-copy services to carrier-grade
availability, while concurrently scaling B4 to accommodate
100x more traffic. Our key challenge is balancing the tension
introduced by hierarchy required for scalability, the partitioning
required for availability, and the capacity asymmetry
inherent to the construction and operation of any large-scale
network. We discuss our approach to managing this tension:
i) we design a custom hierarchical network topology for both
horizontal and vertical software scaling, ii) we manage inherent
capacity asymmetry in hierarchical topologies using
a novel traffic engineering algorithm without packet encapsulation,
and iii) we re-architect switch forwarding rules
via two-stage matching/hashing to deal with asymmetric
network failures at scale.

Source: http://delivery.acm.org/10.1145/3240000/3230545/p74-hong.pdf?ip=


Andromeda: Performance, Isolation, and Velocity at Scale in Cloud Network Virtualization

This paper presents our design and experience with Andromeda,
Google Cloud Platform’s network virtualization
stack. Our production deployment poses several challenging
requirements, including performance isolation among
customer virtual networks, scalability, rapid provisioning
of large numbers of virtual hosts, bandwidth and latency
largely indistinguishable from the underlying hardware,
and high feature velocity combined with high availability.
Andromeda is designed around a flexible hierarchy of
flow processing paths. Flows are mapped to a programming
path dynamically based on feature and performance
requirements. We introduce the Hoverboard programming
model, which uses gateways for the long tail of low bandwidth
flows, and enables the control plane to program
network connectivity for tens of thousands of VMs in
seconds. The on-host dataplane is based around a highperformance
OS bypass software packet processing path.
CPU-intensive per packet operations with higher latency
targets are executed on coprocessor threads. This architecture
allows Andromeda to decouple feature growth from
fast path performance, as many features can be implemented
solely on the coprocessor path. We demonstrate
that the Andromeda datapath achieves performance that is
competitive with hardware while maintaining the flexibility
and velocity of a software-based architecture.

Source: https://www.usenix.org/system/files/conference/nsdi18/nsdi18-dalton.pdf

Taking the Edge off with Espresso: Scale, Reliability and Programmability for Global Internet Peering

We present the design of Espresso, Google’s SDN-based Internet
peering edge routing infrastructure. This architecture grew out of a
need to exponentially scale the Internet edge cost-effectively and to
enable application-aware routing at Internet-peering scale. Espresso
utilizes commodity switches and host-based routing/packet process-
ing to implement a novel fine-grained traffic engineering capability.
Overall, Espresso provides Google a scalable peering edge that is
programmable, reliable, and integrated with global traffic systems.
Espresso also greatly accelerated deployment of new networking
features at our peering edge. Espresso has been in production for
two years and serves over 22% of Google’s total traffic to the Inter-

Source: http://delivery.acm.org/10.1145/3100000/3098854/p432-Yap.pdf?ip=

Espresso makes Google cloud faster, more available and cost effective by extending SDN to the public internet

Today, we gave a keynote presentation at the Open Networking Summit, where we shared details about Espresso, Google’s peering edge architecture—the latest offering in our Software Defined Networking (SDN) strategy. Espresso has been in production for over two years and routes 20 percent of our total traffic to the internet—and growing. It’s changing the way traffic is directed at the peering edge, delivering unprecedented scale, flexibility and efficiency.

Source: https://www.blog.google/topics/google-cloud/making-google-cloud-faster-more-available-and-cost-effective-extending-sdn-public-internet-espresso/

Cutting the Cord: a Robust Wireless Facilities Network for Data Centers

Today’s network control and management traffic are limited by
their reliance on existing data networks. Fate sharing in this context
is highly undesirable, since control traffic has very different availability
and traffic delivery requirements. In this paper, we explore
the feasibility of building a dedicated wireless facilities network for
data centers. We propose Angora, a low-latency facilities network
using low-cost, 60GHz beamforming radios that provides robust
paths decoupled from the wired network, and flexibility to adapt to
workloads and network dynamics. We describe our solutions to address
challenges in link coordination, link interference and network
failures. Our testbed measurements and simulation results show
that Angora enables large number of low-latency control paths to
run concurrently, while providing low latency end-to-end message
delivery with high tolerance for radio and rack failures.

Source: https://static.googleusercontent.com/media/research.google.com/en//pubs/archive/43860.pdf

Lessons learned from B4, Google’s SDN WAN

Google’s B4 wide area network was first revealed several years ago. The outside observer might have thought, “Google’s B4 is finished. I wonder what they’re going to do next.” Turns out, once any network is in production @scale, there’s a continued need to make it better. Subhasree Mandal covered the reality of how Google iterated multiple times on different parts of B4 to improve its performance, availability, and scalability. Several of the challenges and solutions that Subhasree detailed were definitely at the intersection of networking and distributed systems. B4 was covered in a SIGCOMM 2013 paper from Google.